How to Sell Cards
Learn how to sell your cards through the Face to Face Games buylist or trade-in programs, including grading, pricing, and payment options.
Can I negotiate the buylist offer?
Face to Face Games updates buylist pricing based on the current market, so we do not accept price negotiations on buylist offers. If you would like certain items returned, simply reply to your service ticket to request them back.
Do you buy BGS or PSA graded cards?
We do purchase professionally graded cards (PSA, BGS, etc.). However, we do not pay a premium for grading. Graded cards are removed from their case and evaluated using our in-house grading standards. If you prefer to keep the card sealed in its grade
Do you buy non-English cards?
We do buy foreign cards; however, due to lower market demand, non-English cards are purchased at a reduced rate compared to English versions. To check your card’s eligibility or estimated value, open a service ticket and our team will review your sub
How long do I have to ship my cards after accepting the offer?
Please ship your cards within 5 business days of accepting your buylist offer to lock in the quoted prices. If your package is sent after this timeframe, prices may be subject to change based on current market values.
How should I ship my cards safely?
To help ensure your cards arrive safely and maintain their value, please follow these shipping guidelines:. Preparing Your Package. Shipping Recommendations. We strongly recommend using tracked and insured shipping, as Face to Face Games is not respo
I disagree with my card grading — What can I do?
Card grading can be subjective, so we recommend reviewing our Grading Guide to better understand our evaluation standards. If you disagree with the grading, you may request your cards back as long as payment has not yet been issued (typically within
My card was “pack fresh” — Why isn’t it graded near mint?
A card being freshly opened from a pack does not guarantee a Near Mint (NM) grade. Manufacturing issues, printing defects, handling during packaging, and surface imperfections can affect condition before the card is even opened. We grade cards based
Some cards are missing from my grading confirmation email — what should I do?
First, check the comments section of your buylist order. When cards arrive with significant damage (worse than Moderately Played), we:. If you still can’t locate the missing items, it may be a system or save error. Please reply to your service ticket
When will my buylist order be processed?
Buylist orders are typically processed within 10 business days after we receive your package. Please note that processing may take longer during high-volume periods. To avoid delays, ensure the following before shipping your order:. Missing informati
When will I receive payment for my buylist order?
Payments are normally issued within 48 business hours after you approve your final offer. If we do not receive a reply within that timeframe, the offer will be considered approved automatically, and we will proceed with payment.
Will I be contacted with my grading results?
Once your order has been graded, you will receive an email with:. If we do not hear from you within 48 hours of receiving your grading email, we will consider the offer approved and queue your payment. To request returns or decline the offer, simply
How do I sell cards to Face to Face Games?
You can find full instructions on how to sell your cards on our Buylist page. If you still have questions after reviewing it, feel free to open a support ticket and our team will be happy to guide you through the process.
One of my cards was marked as counterfeit — Can I get it back?
We test all incoming cards using industry-standard authentication methods to prevent counterfeit cards from entering the community. As per Wizards of the Coast policy on counterfeits (5.K) and our company standards:. Face to Face Games reserves the r
Do you buy large amounts of bulk?
At events, we currently only purchase bulk Rares, Mythics, and Foils. Bulk commons / uncommons are not accepted at this time.